The Evolution of Refrigerants

---

The refrigeration industry has been in a state of constant evolution since the 1920s. At the center of this evolution has always been one critical component: the refrigerant. Early refrigerants like ammonia (R-717), chloromethane (R-40), and sulfur dioxide (R-764) posed serious safety risks, including toxicity and flammability. This was the biggest obstacle to the widespread adoption of refrigeration and air conditioning in homes and workplaces. The industry needed a solution that was both safe and efficient, and this quest initiated a journey of innovation and adaptation that continues to this day.

The Second Generation: CFCs and the Safety Revolution

In 1928, a revolution in refrigeration history occurred through a collaboration between Frigidaire and DuPont. Thomas Midgley, Jr., and his team developed the first commercial Chlorofluorocarbon (CFC), dichlorodifluoromethane, known to all as R-12. These “safe” refrigerants were neither toxic nor flammable. These properties enabled the rapid proliferation of refrigeration systems, and they became known as second-generation refrigerants. However, this sense of security would be overshadowed years later by a much larger global problem.

The Ozone Crisis and the Birth of the Montreal Protocol

In 1974, two University of California professors, Frank Rowland and Mario Molina, published a paper highlighting the damage that chlorine could cause to the ozone layer in the stratosphere. This scientific discovery turned the world’s attention to the unseen danger of CFCs. The depletion of the ozone layer meant the weakening of the shield that protects our planet from harmful ultraviolet rays.

This global concern culminated in the signing of one of history’s most successful international environmental agreements in 1987: the Montreal Protocol. This protocol phased out the production and use of chlorine-containing CFCs and, later, HCFCs (Hydrochlorofluorocarbons). This development pushed the industry to develop third-generation refrigerants.

The Third Generation: HFCs and a New Foe: Global Warming

Following the Montreal Protocol, Hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), which do not contain chlorine and therefore do not harm the ozone layer, were developed. These refrigerants seemed like the perfect solution to the ozone crisis. However, HFCs also came at a price: a high Global Warming Potential (GWP). Like CFCs, HFCs were greenhouse gases, trapping heat in the atmosphere and contributing to climate change.

This new awareness once again mobilized the global community.

The Kigali Amendment and the Age of Global Regulations

In October 2016, a historic amendment was made to the Montreal Protocol in Kigali, Rwanda. With the Kigali Amendment, HFCs were also included in the list of controlled substances. This agreement symbolized the commitment of the world’s nations to combat the global warming impact of HFCs.

Even before Kigali, pioneering regions like the European Union (with its F-gas regulation) and the state of California in the USA (with the AB 32 Act) had already implemented regulations restricting the use of HFCs and imposing requirements such as leak inspections and record-keeping.

The Fourth Generation: HFOs and the Flammability Hurdle

The impending phase-down of HFCs has directed the industry towards fourth-generation refrigerants: Hydrofluoroolefins (HFOs). HFOs have significantly lower GWP values compared to HFCs. However, this new generation of refrigerants faces a significant hurdle: mild flammability (A2L class).

For HFOs to be widely adopted, new safety standards must be established by organizations like ASHRAE, the EPA, and UL, and these standards must be adapted into local codes.

Today’s Design Philosophy: “Less is More”

All these regulations and environmental pressures have fundamentally changed the philosophy of refrigeration system design. The focus is no longer just on efficiency but also on minimizing environmental impact. The prominent trends in this direction are:

• Reducing Refrigerant Charge: Minimizing the total amount of refrigerant in systems reduces the impact of a potential leak.

• Leak-Tight Systems: Preventing releases to the atmosphere by using tighter, leak-proof pipe connections and components.

• Indirect and Cascade Systems: Systems where the primary refrigerant (HFC/HFO) is used only in a compact unit in the machine room, and heat is transported by a secondary fluid like glycol, are becoming increasingly popular. This approach dramatically reduces both the charge amount and the risk of leakage.

In conclusion, the story of refrigerants is a reflection of humanity’s search for a balance between technological progress and environmental responsibility. This journey, which began with safety concerns, continues today with the goal of protecting the future of our planet.

---